Stumble it!

Photoshop vs Plugin: Who Has the Best 1-Step Noise Reduction?

By J. Luzatto posted in Design Photography, Web Design Tools on 29-09-2009

Photoshop vs Plugin: Who Has the Best 1-Step Noise Reduction?

If you find your photographs like mine, far from perfect, then I bet you have the need to edit.  One of the main problems from digital cameras today is the amount of noise you will have in your photograph. Even while using a tripod, you may still experience movement. This is one of the first corrections I make in Photoshop, as 99% of my photos are hand-held. I’m sure I’m not alone.

Today we would like to share with you a video describing the benefits from Topaz’s DeNoise, a plugin for Adobe Photoshop designed for fine tuning the noise reduction in your photographs.  While Photoshop and the other photo editing software can adjust the noise in your images, DeNoise makes it quite simple and with results that will leave the amateur photographer in shock as they see their photos correct.  Simply amazing!

DeNoise: How it Works

DeNoise detects correct amount of  noise reduction needed in your image and additional slider adjustments are not necessary unless you want a particular look to your photo..  If you choose to adjust manually, move all slider adjustments to the left.  By moving the ‘Suppress Noise’ lever to the right, your noise will disappear.  You can depress the ‘View Original Image’ tab at any time to view comparisons with the original.

Pros

  • Easy to use
  • Automatically detects amount of noise reduction
  • Preserves the image edges and in some cases will restore edge and line detail
  • Six presets for noise reduction and adjustments

Cons

  • When using some of the presets, you may lose contrast in your image.
  • The price tag.  No, this is not a freebie.

You can download the trial version of DeNoise at Topaz’s website.

Now for some comparisons with a photo I took while at Catalina Island.  As you can imagine, animals outside the zoos are not accustomed to being photographed and not always cooperative.

The Original Image

Other than adjusting the exposure and white balance which I’ll do at a later time, my goal here is to remove as much noise as possible without compromising the definition of the feathers.
catalina-pelican-original

Once you install the Topaz plugins, you will be able to find them under filters as shown below.  For this comparison, we will only use the DeNoise plugin.

catalina-pelican-topaz-location

With each preset you select, you are able to preview the image before making a decision.
catalina-pelican-topaz-noise-adjustment-2

The noise was adjusted in this photo using the preset ‘JPEG Strong Noise’  with Topaz DeNoise
catalina-pelican-topaz-noise-adjustment-3

The noise was adjusted in this photo using the default noise reduction in Adobe Photoshop.    Though it has a nice smooth appearance, Adobe has lost the definition in the feathers.
catalina-pelican-adobe-noise

Original vs Topaz DeNoise – Edited

At a magnification of 200%, you will see the Topaz DeNoise image on the right has removed the noise.   The background is more smooth and  no real loss in feather definition.
original-topaz-200x

Original vs Adobe Edited

Adobe defaults for noise reduction smoothed too much of the image and lost clarity.  Adobe edited image on the right.
original-adobe-comparison

You can manually adjust the noise settings with both Adobe and the plugin, Topaz DeNoise, but when using default settings or presets, you will need to decide how you want your images to appear when you are finished.



  • Thanks for brushes
  • HTML vs Flash.... the endless war. But Flash can co-exist with HTML and still it has a long road left to travel.

    Thanks for the article.
  • "At the end, the answers might come from the web design community, if it decides to fight for the right to Flash." It would be nice if designers had that power... but do we?

    While I love Flash, my use of it is often dictated by the clients reaction to it, which often stems from what they think their target market thinks about it.

    There are more internet users than web designers, giving me reason to think they're the ones who will make the decision.
  • noelwiggins
    good inspirada and good timing

    --

    Thanks and Regards

    Noel for Nopun.com
    a graphic design studio
  • polla
    Thanks
blog comments powered by Disqus